Knowing when to hire another employee can be one of the harder decisions for a growing business. The team is busy, work is piling up, and everyone seems to be doing a little more than they should.
The obvious answer is to recruit someone. And sometimes, that is exactly what you need to do.
But something I have learned over the years is that being busy does not always mean you need another person. Sometimes the issue is how work is shared, how roles have changed, or whether the people you already have are being given the right support.
I have seen businesses rush into recruitment because they feel under pressure, only to find that the same problems are still there once the new person joins. Before writing a job advert, I think it is worth asking a few questions about what the business needs and where the pressure is coming from.
One way to work through this is PRET, which stands for Purpose, Resource, Employees and Time.
These four areas help you make a more informed decision about recruitment, the team you already have, and what needs to happen next.
What is PRET and how can it help SMEs?
PRET is a simple way to review your people’s needs before making decisions about recruitment or team structure.
It looks at four areas:
- Purpose: Why does this role exist, and what does the business need it to achieve?
- Resource: Do you have the right people, skills and capacity to manage the work?
- Employees: Are your current team supported, motivated and able to develop?
- Time: What happens if you delay making a decision?
For small and medium-sized businesses, thinking about these areas together can help you avoid rushed recruitment decisions.
You may discover that you do need to hire. You may realise that an existing employee is ready for more responsibility. Or you might find that the structure of the team needs attention before you bring someone new into it.
Let’s look at each area.
Purpose: Why are you hiring?
This is always where I would start.
When a manager tells me they need another person, I want to understand why. Has someone left? Is the business growing? Are customers waiting too long? Is a manager spending their day doing work that should sit elsewhere?
There is usually a reason behind the vacancy, but it is worth exploring before deciding what the role should look like. For example, imagine your Office Manager is leaving after five years. The natural response might be to recruit another Office Manager with the same job description.
But think about how much the business may have changed in those five years. Perhaps the finance work has moved elsewhere. Customer enquiries have increased. The team now needs someone who can manage processes rather than office administration.
Recruiting an exact replacement could mean missing the opportunity to bring in someone better suited to what the business needs today. Before hiring, ask yourself what problem the role needs to solve and what you would want that person to achieve in their first 12 months.
Start with the reason for the hire. The job title can come afterwards.
Resource: Do you need another person?
This is where I think many growing businesses need to spend more time.
When people are stretched, adding another employee can seem like the fastest answer. But first, look at how the work is being managed.
Is the workload genuinely too much for the current team? Are responsibilities shared fairly? Do people have the skills and tools they need? Is work being duplicated because no one is quite sure who owns it?
Sometimes the answer is to hire. Other times, you may need to review job descriptions, change how tasks are shared or provide training. For example, a business might want another administrator because its Operations Manager is overwhelmed.
But when you look more closely, the manager may be spending hours each week chasing updates, checking work and answering questions that other people could handle with better systems or training. In that case, another administrator may add cost without solving the cause of the problem.
Workforce planning for SMEs should begin with understanding the work that needs doing and whether your team has the capacity to do it. Of course, there is a balance. You cannot keep asking good people to absorb more work indefinitely. If demand has grown and the team is already working at full capacity, recruitment may be overdue. The important thing is knowing which situation you are dealing with.
Employees: Are you getting the best from your team?
I have always believed that businesses perform better when they take the time to understand their people. Yet this is often the part of recruitment planning that gets overlooked.
You might have someone in the business who is ready to step up, but nobody has asked about their ambitions. Another person may be struggling because their role has changed, or because they need more direction from their manager.
Before recruiting externally, it is worth having those conversations. Do your employees know what is expected of them? Are they getting feedback? Can they see opportunities to develop? Do they feel their contribution is recognised?
I am a big believer in giving people room to grow, especially in smaller businesses where formal promotion opportunities may be limited. Development does not always mean a new title or becoming a manager. It might mean taking ownership of a project, learning a new skill or gaining more responsibility in an area they enjoy.
These conversations can also help with employee retention for small businesses. If someone feels overlooked or stuck, they may start looking elsewhere. You could end up recruiting for two vacancies when a little more attention to development might have helped you keep a good employee.
This is one reason I am so passionate about our People Engagement Programme at GoGecko. Understanding how people work, what motivates them and where they want to go can change how a business manages its team.
And sometimes, the person you need is already sitting in front of you.
Time: What is the cost of waiting?
Time is often the hidden cost in people decisions.
I understand why business owners delay recruitment. Taking on another salary is a commitment, especially when you are running an SME and watching costs carefully. But leaving a role vacant also has a cost.
Existing employees may be covering extra work. Managers may be spending less time with customers. Projects may be delayed, and service can suffer. There is also the risk of losing good people because they have been carrying too much for too long.
The same applies to decisions about performance and team relationships. A difficult conversation that gets put off rarely becomes easier. Small frustrations can grow, and by the time someone decides to deal with them, the impact may be much wider.
So when considering when to hire another employee, think about what happens if you wait another three or six months.
Will the team cope? Will customer service be affected? Could the delay cost more than bringing someone in?
You do not want to rush into the wrong hire, but waiting until everyone is exhausted is not a good recruitment strategy either.
How PRET works when a small business is growing
Let’s imagine a growing customer service business in Worthing.
The business has ten employees and customer enquiries have increased. The manager is working longer hours, response times are slipping, and the team has asked for more help.
The immediate thought is to recruit another Customer Service Advisor. Using PRET, the business can look at the decision from four angles.
Purpose: The main need is to improve customer response times and take pressure off the manager.
Resource: A review shows that the manager is still handling several tasks that could be shared. However, customer demand has also increased enough to justify more capacity.
Employees: An existing team member is interested in taking on more responsibility and could manage part of the customer process with some training.
Time: Waiting too long could put further pressure on the team and affect customer relationships.
The outcome may be to develop the existing employee, change how responsibilities are shared and recruit someone for a more focused support role. The business still hires, but now it has a better understanding of what it needs.
That is the benefit of taking a little time to review the situation before starting recruitment.
How do you know when it is time to hire another employee?
After working through PRET, you should have a better sense of whether recruitment is the right next step.
If demand is growing, the workload is likely to continue, and your existing team cannot reasonably take on more, there is a strong case for hiring. You should also know what the new person will be responsible for, what skills they need and how their role will fit alongside the rest of the team.
That makes it easier to write a job description, set a realistic salary and assess candidates against what the business needs.
Good recruitment planning for small businesses also means looking ahead. If you know you will need someone in three months, start thinking about the role now. Hiring takes time, particularly when you need someone with specialist skills or experience. The earlier you understand your requirements, the better prepared you will be when you are ready to recruit.
Before your next hire, look at the team you already have
My advice to any growing business is to spend a little time thinking about your people before making the next recruitment decision.
A new employee can bring fresh skills, take pressure off the team and help the business grow. But the role needs to have a purpose, and the people already there need to be considered too.
PRET gives you four areas to think about before making that commitment. You may find that recruitment is the answer. You may need to develop an existing employee, review responsibilities or address a management issue first.
At GoGecko, we help SMEs with both sides of that decision.
Through our recruitment consultancy, we can help you shape the role, understand the market and find someone who fits your business. Our People Engagement Programme can also help you look at how your current team is working, where responsibilities need attention and how to support people as the business grows.
If you are thinking about recruiting, or you know something needs to change within your team, let’s have a conversation before you make your next people decision.
Sometimes an outside view is all you need to work out where to start.